Is Merritt Island or Cocoa Beach Better for Waterfront
Living?
A Space Coast Showdown by Carrie Liotta, Your Local Waterfront Realtor
Florida’s Space Coast isn’t just about rocket launches—it’s one of the most desirable places in the state for waterfront living. But if you’re dreaming of coffee by the dock or sunrise surf sessions, one big question always comes up: Is Merritt Island or Cocoa Beach better for waterfront living?
The truth? It depends on your lifestyle. Merritt Island is for boaters and privacy seekers. Cocoa Beach is for surfers and social butterflies. Both are amazing—but they deliver totally different versions of the Florida dream.
🌴 Quick Overview: The Vibe of Each
🏝 Merritt Island Nestled between the Indian River Lagoon and Banana River, Merritt Island feels like your own private peninsula. You’ll find quiet neighborhoods, wildlife preserves, and homes with deep-water canal access that let you boat straight to the Intracoastal. It’s peaceful, residential, and perfect for those who value space, privacy, and nature.
🏄 Cocoa Beach On the flip side, Cocoa Beach sits directly on the Atlantic Ocean, famous for its surf culture, vibrant restaurants, and walkable downtown. It’s where you can go from your front door to the waves in 60 seconds flat. It’s lively, social, and full of energy, events, and beach-town charm.
Both are part of Brevard County and less than 10 miles apart—so you can easily enjoy both worlds.
💰 Waterfront Real Estate: Price, Value, and Lifestyle
CategoryMerritt IslandCocoa BeachMedian Sale Price (2025)$446,000 (down slightly YoY)$525,000 (up 39% YoY)Price per Sq Ft$269$357Waterfront OptionsCanal homes, riverfront estates, no HOA neighborhoodsOceanfront condos, beachside cottagesLifestyle FeelPrivate docks, boating, family-friendlyBeachfront, vibrant, tourist-friendlyRental Income PotentialModerateHigh (Airbnb + vacation demand)
👉 In short: Merritt Island gives you more property for your money, while Cocoa Beach gives you direct access to the ocean and stronger rental potential.
⚓ Water Access & Outdoor Living
- Merritt Island: A boater’s paradise. Most waterfront homes have docks, lifts, or access to canals leading straight into the Indian or Banana River. You can kayak with dolphins, fish from your backyard, or watch rocket launches from the water.
- Cocoa Beach: All about the Atlantic—surfing, paddleboarding, beach walks, and pier sunsets. If you love feeling the ocean breeze and the buzz of beach life, it’s unbeatable.
Insider Tip: Many locals choose Merritt Island for their primary residence and Cocoa Beach for their weekend fun.
🏫 Schools & Community
Brevard County is home to top-ranked schools with strong STEM programs connected to NASA and the space industry.
- Merritt Island’s Edgewood Jr./Sr. High ranks among Florida’s best.
- Cocoa Beach’s Jr./Sr. High offers International Baccalaureate programs and strong extracurriculars.
Both areas are family-friendly, but Merritt Island feels quieter, while Cocoa Beach offers a more active, social community.
🏡 Lifestyle & Amenities
Merritt Island:
- Boating, wildlife, and peaceful evenings.
- Close to Cocoa Village for dining, live music, and local events.
- Great for full-time residents or families who want space and serenity.
Cocoa Beach:
- Endless events, bars, surf shops, and live music at the pier.
- Walkable community with a mix of locals and visitors.
- Perfect for beach lovers, retirees, and investors.
🌀 Safety, Insurance & Maintenance
Both areas face similar flood and hurricane exposure, so newer elevated construction and updated seawalls are key. Merritt Island’s interior neighborhoods often have lower insurance premiums than direct oceanfront Cocoa Beach properties, where salt exposure increases maintenance.
✅ Pros & Cons Summary
CategoryMerritt IslandCocoa BeachWaterfront TypeLagoon, river, canalOceanfront, beachPrivacyHighModerateWalkabilityLimitedExcellentRental PotentialModerateHighVibeLaid-back, natureEnergetic, socialBest ForBoaters, families, full-time livingSurfers, snowbirds, investors
🏁 The Verdict: It’s About Your Version of Paradise
There’s no “better,” only what’s better for you.
- If you dream of launching your boat from your backyard, spotting dolphins, and soaking in tranquil sunsets—Merritt Island is your spot.
- If your vision of paradise is toes in the sand, beach cafés, and ocean sunrises, Cocoa Beach is calling your name.
Either way, you’re on the Space Coast—where rocket launches light up your backyard and the ocean is never far away.
🌅 Thinking About Waterfront Living?
I’m Carrie Liotta, local Space Coast REALTOR® and Waterfront Certified Specialist, proud to call Merritt Island home. If you’re comparing waterfront properties or want a local’s insight on canal depths, bridge clearances, or the best boating communities—I’ve got you covered.
➡️ Or sign up for my Space Coast newsletter HERE for insider tips and new waterfront opportunities, current listings, local guides, and market updates.
Merritt Island Waterfront Homes: HERE